Actors
| Charactor | Performed By | |
| Coalhouse Walker Jr. | Brian Stokes Mitchell | |
| Tateh | Peter Friedman | |
| Mother | Marin Mazzie | |
| Sarah | Audra McDonald | |
| Father | Mark Jacoby | |
| Emma Goldman | Judy Kay | |
| Harry Houdini | Jim Corti | |
| Booker Washington | Tommy Hollis | |
| Evelyn Nesbit | Janine LaManna | |
| Younger Brother | Steven Sutcliffe | |
| JP Morgan | Mike O'Carroll | |
| Little Boy | Alex Strange | |
| Little Girl | Lea Michele | |
